Skip to main content

Is PR a leadership discipline? Professor Anne Gregory has the answer

Professor Anne Gregory, Professor Emeritus at the University of Huddersfield and a former president of the CIPR, argues that public relations belongs in leadership decision-making, not in a management silo. On episode 71 of PR in the Real World, she tells Tony Garner why crises now turn on character, and why AI needs a human at the helm. 

By Tony Garner, Managing Director, Viva PR 

Earlier this year, at an AI and PR conference, I was introduced to Anne Gregory before one of the morning sessions. Not long after, she was on stage and told the room that one phrase troubled her more than most: “human in the loop”. It was a true mike drop moment. 

She says it makes  people sound incidental, we’re in the loop, but not in control. She wanted “human at the helm” instead. 

I’ve used this line ever since, but of course I give Anne the credit. 

Bering at the helm is a common thread for this episode. Anne was president of the Institute of Public Relations when it went after chartered status, and she has spent most of the years since making the case that communication sits inside leadership. So I asked her whether, more than 20 years on, the profession has lived up to the charter. 

“Yes and no,” she said.

So who is Professor Anne Gregory? 

Anne Gregory is Professor Emeritus at Huddersfield Business School, University of Huddersfield, where she was Professor of Corporate Communication from 2014. She was president of the Institute of Public Relations in 2004 and led its successful bid for chartered status. She chaired the Global Alliance for Public Relations and Communication Management from 2013 to 2015 and has reviewed UK Government communication. Her awards include the Sir Stephen Tallents Medal and the PRSA Atlas Award for Lifetime Achievement. 

Links: University of Huddersfield profile · University of Huddersfield news: two global achievement awards

Why does PR belong in leadership rather than management? 

Anne Gregory argues that public relations is undervalued when it sits on the organisation chart amongst many other management functions. She argues that if you take away the money and you still have an organisation. Take away the buildings, as Covid did, and you still have one. But taking away communications, you have nothing.  

“You cannot have an organisation unless people talk to each other, the boss shares a vision, unless we share our tasks and agree what we’re going to do… (If you do not have communication), you don’t have an organisation.” 

Professor Anne Gregory, University of Huddersfield 

Let’s get to grips with what she means. Management, in her terms, is about implementing decisions efficiently. Leadership is where the decisions get made, and a leader who doesn’t know what stakeholders will tolerate, support or object to will make worse ones. 

And, if comms reports into a silo, it only hears about decisions once they’ve been taken. The danger here is clear — for an in-house team, the place to raise the stakeholder view is the draft board paper. By the time the press release is being written, the decision is already made.

Where should PR evaluation start? 

Anne Gregory says evaluation should start with what people reasonably expect of an organisation, alongside what the organisation wants from them. She runs it with organisations as a two-column exercise. 

“Let’s have a balance sheet. On one side, what do you want to achieve? What are your objectives and who are the people that you want to achieve this with? And then on the other side, what are their objectives? What do they want from you?” 

Professor Anne Gregory, University of Huddersfield 

Those expectations are usually reasonable, she says, and when the two columns are put side by side they are “like ships in the night”. 

A report that only fills in the left-hand column can show every target hit while the people in the right-hand column lose patience. Add one question at the planning stage, what does this group reasonably expect from us, and you have something to measure on both sides.

Why are crises now about character rather than competence? 

Anne Gregory says that ten years ago most crises tested whether an organisation could do the job: make the product properly, handle the recall quickly. Now they test how it behaves. She cites work by Rod Cartwright and by Rupert Younger at Oxford. 

“Now crises are about character, how organisations behave, how a chief executive or somebody in authority, you know, ignores the rules and thinks that [they] don’t apply to them.” 

Professor Anne Gregory, University of Huddersfield 

She separates overt governance (the law, the regulator, shareholders) from covert governance, the unwritten expectations people hold. If that sounds like a tricky concept to wrap your brain around she gives examples like the Downing Street parties during lockdown, and chief executive bonuses rising while jobs are cut. In both these instances there is a distance between the story an organisation tells and what people experience of it. This she calls “the legitimacy gap”.

How does a comms team stop being treated as a delivery function? 

Anne Gregory says communicators get labelled by what they talk about, and too many of them talk about output. 

“Our comfort blanket is doing stuff… If you’re constantly talking about ‘I’ll do a bit of content for TikTok’ or this, that and the other, that’s how you’ll be labelled. No wonder people say, come and deliver this for me.” 

Professor Anne Gregory, University of Huddersfield 

She says the alternative is a leader saying: “I never realised, actually, that there’s a community around us that’s really hacked off because our lorries are going through at 6:00 in the morning.” Comms often know that first, because they are engaged with the community. Lorries at 6am are a reputation issue, a planning issue and, eventually, a licence-to-operate issue. Take that to the leadership team and you’ll be asked for advice. Take a content calendar and you’ll be asked for content.

What does “human at the helm” mean for AI in comms? 

Anne Gregory prefers “human at the helm” to “human in the loop”, because the second phrase puts people beside the technology instead of in charge of it. 

“If we talk about humans in the loop, well, it just sounds a little bit like we’re incidental. You know, we’re in the loop, but we’re not actually in control.” 

Professor Anne Gregory, University of Huddersfield 

She also makes a really strong point about AI skills. “Unless you know how to write, how are you going to correct AI-written text? Unless you know how to research, how do you know that the data on which it’s basing its content is okay?”  

Pausing entry-level hiring, she says, is “a very short-term perspective”. For governance, she points to Rolls-Royce’s Aletheia Framework, which pairs values-based principles with an audit of who benefits and who could be harmed. 

When someone asks why you’re using AI the way you are, an audit trail like this can show them is a better answer than a statement. Anne thinks comms should run that check, because comms is used to act on behalf of stakeholders.

The Viva View 

Ooo – that was a good one. Lots to chew on over a brew and a hobnob. What stood out for me was the balance sheet stuff. In my head we forget about the people. Most comms plans are written from one side of the balance sheet. 

Anne’s two-column exercise needs nothing more than a sheet of paper. The left-hand column fills itself: objectives, audiences, key messages, a launch date. The right-hand column, what people want from the organisation, tends to get a line, if that, and (let’s be honest here) it’s usually written by someone who hasn’t asked them. 

Her point about ethics and character is a god one too. A plan can be well crafted and still fall over if the leaders won’t stand behind it. If comms is taking one line while the board acts another way, the audience can smell it. You don’t need fancy graphs and evaluation reports for that. 

So my take away. A little Monday morning exercise. For the next big plan, one question: would the people in the right-hand column recognise the organisation described in the left? 

Listen to the full episode 

Episode 71 of PR in the Real World, Tuesday 17th November 2026

Listen on Spotify · Listen on Apple Podcasts · Watch on YouTube

00:00:00:00 – 00:00:07:28
Tony
This is a Viva podcast.

00:00:08:00 – 00:00:27:21
Anne
It’s a really turbulent, dangerous, crisis ridden world out there. It’s such a speed and such a reach that we’ve never known before. If you take communication away, you cannot have an organization. We decide what sort of society we want. The time to make those decisions is now.

00:00:27:23 – 00:00:52:16
Tony
Hello and welcome to PR in the Real World with me, Tony Garner. I’m really excited about today’s episode. I’m speaking with Doctor and Gregory and a world renowned academic, and Arthur, a consultant in PR and currently serving as a professor emeritus of Corporate Communications at the University of Huddersfield and highly regarded a leading authority in PR. What she’s got to say really matters.

00:00:52:17 – 00:01:18:25
Tony
So stay tuned. Let’s get into it. So and thank you so much for giving us your time today. I was, going through the kind of list of achievements that you’ve you’ve been of things that you’ve been involved in your, your career. And one of the things that popped out is that you led the campaign for the Institute of Public Relations to gain chartered status in 2004.

00:01:18:28 – 00:01:34:10
Tony
So when you look back and reflect more than 20 years on, do you think the professions lived up to that standing, that that was it worth that fight? Or he still in some respects, along the same lines.

00:01:34:12 – 00:01:57:15
Anne
Well, so yes and no. No, I think Tony. So yes, we are struggling for respect. Still got lots of challenges. For example, we still not quite sure what we call ourselves. Is it public relations? Is it strategic communications or corporate affairs or whatever? And and that’s not a great assistance to us, I think. We can’t name the discipline.

00:01:57:16 – 00:02:20:05
Anne
Precisely. We still struggle with the strategic role at the top table. Oh, well, that is changing now. I’ll come back to that in a second. And we’re not involved automatically in decision making in organizations. But again, that’s beginning to change a little bit as well. I think we’re still seen by some people as a delivery function.

00:02:20:06 – 00:02:40:23
Anne
You know, we make the decisions. We would go off and communicate them. We still haven’t won the battle with evaluation. So there’s lots of things that keep recurring. You know the saying from 20 years ago. But in some areas we’ve made real progress, I think, Tony. So and I think it’s partly the circumstances in which we find ourselves.

00:02:40:24 – 00:03:10:23
Anne
You know, it’s a really turbulent, dangerous, crisis ridden world out there. And we always know that crises offer great opportunities for public relations professionals. And so that sort of senior risk manager, that being able to look around corners and spot the issues that are coming towards an organization, how it should position itself in relation to those crises, all part of our back.

00:03:10:27 – 00:03:29:07
Anne
And increasingly called on, I think, and because of all that sort of change that’s going on around us, Tony, I think there’s a big role for us in trying to make sense of it all. So sense maker in chief, if you like, but also a sense. Give us a when you know our stakeholders are trying to work with us.

00:03:29:07 – 00:04:04:03
Anne
What does this all mean for me? So does that opportunity to share a lot more with our the people who work with us and for us, and together to try and find a way forward, because things are incredibly complex at the moment. I think we’ve seen, you know, internal communications, a huge step change in that as, CEOs realize that corporate culture, everybody’s a representative now, and that corporate culture piece is really, really important and can be the life or death of an organization.

00:04:04:03 – 00:04:28:18
Anne
So, yes, still struggling in some respects, those old sort of chestnuts keep coming back. But I think there has been real progress in some ways. And I think this move towards chartered status and becoming chartered practitioners is so important on this. We now take our education seriously and before it was all well, we’ve all done it this way and we’ve always done it this way.

00:04:28:21 – 00:04:35:05
Anne
Not good enough now. So we are taking ourselves as a profession much more seriously. I think as well.

00:04:35:07 – 00:05:04:17
Tony
I mean, to to some of those points. I mean, the world has changed around us as well, isn’t it? You know, since 2004 that the rise of social media and now more latterly, the rise of AI and the impact that that can have so quickly on reputations, I’m guessing when this was is being argued and discussed and frameworks, you know, that those things weren’t even like dreamt of the pace of change.

00:05:04:17 – 00:05:14:12
Tony
So and, and and it’s, it’s made it even more important, I guess, for organizations to get the house in order.

00:05:14:15 – 00:05:44:27
Anne
Yeah, absolutely. I think it’s speed. Speed of change. The reach of change. Everybody’s being impacted, you know, sort of globalization, if you like. But also, we’re all on social media now. So the reach of for good and for bad, for stories to get around so quickly has really changed the way that we have to engage, engage with people, the channels of change, but also the nature of the exchanges have changed as well.

00:05:44:29 – 00:06:19:29
Anne
And, you know, the threat towards our relationships and reputations. It’s such a speed and such a reach that we’ve never known before. And you know what? It’s never going to be slower than it is today. It’s only going to speed up. So, again, I think that gives us tremendous opportunities because we are able to shape things to an extent, but we’re also able to have those critical conversations, you know, inside our organizations and outside, because that’s our job really.

00:06:20:01 – 00:06:28:28
Anne
And sort of mentoring senior leaders through this really turbulent environment is is a key area of our work. I believe.

00:06:29:00 – 00:06:51:07
Tony
You talked about evaluation earlier and, and, again, in our world, evaluation typically starts with an organization’s objectives. Did we hit the targets that remove the numbers that we wanted to. You’ve heard that that’s that’s starting in the wrong place. So tell me about where should we be starting?

00:06:51:10 – 00:07:14:01
Anne
Yeah. Well, we need to do that. Clearly. You know, organizations are here to do stuff and they want people to support them. So we do need to set our objectives properly. And we do need to be able to, you know, trying to achieve them if they’re legitimate. Absolutely. But we forget the other half, which is that people have reasonable expectations of us as well.

00:07:14:04 – 00:07:34:21
Anne
And there’s really interesting exercise you could do, which I’ve done with some organizations with, okay, let’s have a like a balance sheet. So on this side, what do you want to achieve? What are your objectives and who are the people that you want to achieve this with. And then on the other side. What are their objectives. What do they want from you?

00:07:34:23 – 00:07:56:28
Anne
And normally those expectations are quite reasonable. They’re not always reasonable. You know we have people who are acting against us, but normally they’re reasonable. And if you put the two together, Tony, it’s like, you know, ships in the night, they’re just not coincident at all. So I think we need to think about evaluation, not just from our point of view and our perspective.

00:07:57:00 – 00:08:22:29
Anne
We need to ask some questions. Well, what what’s the reasonable expectation of this stakeholder or of society or of those people who maybe were not involved in our community but are observing what’s going on and say, well, what are the key questions that they are going to ask? And then, okay, how can we satisfy those? So there’s two sides to this coin, and we never seem to remember that second side.

00:08:23:04 – 00:08:52:11
Anne
We’ve got obligations. People have expectations of us quite happy that we make money. Quite happy that we make decisions in government as long as they feel listen to, and as long as they feel they’re part of the future and we’re not always going to them for an ask. We’re not always demanding of them, but we’re willing to take into account and happy to take into account, you know, their reasonable expectations, because at the end of the day, we are accountable to them.

00:08:52:11 – 00:09:02:12
Anne
Governments get voted out and shareholders and others will act against an organization I don’t like. You don’t like your values. Withdrawing my support. Yeah.

00:09:02:12 – 00:09:18:07
Tony
And interesting. So have you got any kind of examples to to kind of bring that alive that, that thought were you know, perhaps governments have been talking at us, and not really talking with us.

00:09:18:10 – 00:09:45:23
Anne
Yeah. I suppose the classic has to be Covid, you know. Right. Where we were told to stay at home, we mustn’t mix. And then we found out that there were parties going on in Downing Street and, you know, trust that was already beginning to slide. Really took a dive. And it took away the government’s legitimacy to ask us to do things, you know, because we were very dependent on government in Covid.

00:09:45:23 – 00:10:06:10
Anne
So it’s like a double jeopardy. You know, we felt we had to depend on them. We had to believe them. And then when they let us down, it felt as if it’s not only that they’ve let us down. All the sacrifices that we’ve made, they count for nothing, because is one rule for us and it’s another rule for them.

00:10:06:12 – 00:10:37:00
Anne
And another example is, you know, we’re going through tough times, as we know, in the UK and across the world at the moment. And chief executive pay seems to be going up and up and up. And yet, you know, they’re making people redundant. And it’s really offensive when a chief executive’s pay goes up and they get a nice big fat bonus when other people are losing their jobs and communities are being devastated because they’re moving away, maybe to somewhere that’s cheaper.

00:10:37:03 – 00:11:04:09
Anne
And it’s not only about them losing trust, it’s the whole of this sort of ecosystem of trusting society is being nibbled away at. Tony. It’s really dangerous. And so not just for selfish reasons, but because at the end of the day, we have to trust each other and we doing less and less of that. If we’re going to have any sort of society, we’re going to have any sort of connection with anybody.

00:11:04:12 – 00:11:08:06
Anne
There has to be that level of trust. And it’s been threatened.

00:11:08:09 – 00:11:38:24
Tony
That’s. Yeah. And you can see that. And you brought back some bitter tasting memories there, I guess, if you’re listening. But I guess to boil it down, what you’re saying here is that an organization might take all the boxes in terms of its, behavioral objectives, but damage trust at the same time or create another negative. And, and in the process, if they’re not careful, they’re not watching across the kind of whole spectrum.

00:11:38:27 – 00:12:02:01
Anne
Yeah. And the phrase that I use is there’s some over governance rules. You know, you obey the law. You do this because your regulator says so. You do that because your shareholders require you or you fulfill that promise because as a government, you made that promise. So this stuff about covert governance.

00:12:02:04 – 00:12:02:21
Tony
Yeah.

00:12:02:28 – 00:12:29:01
Anne
There’s also this stuff about covert governance, which I say is about expectations. It’s reasonable to expect that a company that’s making a lot of money makes a bigger contribution than a company that’s making a small amount of money. It’s reasonable to expect that behaviors that, you know, people in authority are demanding of us also apply to them. And these are like the unwritten rules.

00:12:29:01 – 00:13:00:22
Anne
It’s like a social contract only. And actually, if you look at the nature of crises at the moment, in work done by Rod Cartwright, for example, and, and Rupert Younger down in Oxford, the nature of crises has changed. So crises normally, well, you know, ten years ago were about competence you know. Did you manufacture that product. Right. Or if there was an accident, did you deal with it competently, do the recall quickly, etc., etc.?

00:13:00:24 – 00:13:30:05
Anne
Now crises are about character, how organizations behave, how a chief executive or somebody in authority, you know, ignores the rules and thinks that it don’t apply to them. And there’s more and more of those character crises. And this is about this over and over governance thing, I think as well, Tony, what’s fair and reasonable and just are the questions that people are asking.

00:13:30:07 – 00:13:50:06
Tony
That’s interesting. I’m trying to kind of I always think, oh, how can I take this upstairs? I’ve got my team upstairs, Beaver. In a way, we’ve got our different kind of frameworks that we work to our reports that we how can we embed this into our practice? That’s always my kind of question here. And and, what is it?

00:13:50:06 – 00:13:59:25
Tony
We need to start asking better, to get a better kind of report that we can give back out to people.

00:13:59:28 – 00:14:19:25
Anne
Yeah, well, I think same rules for us. And first of all, we got to be competent so we don’t overpromise, you know, deliver when we say we’re going to deliver, we use the staff that we say we’re going to use. So we’re competent. And then it is about character. So are we ethical? Do we have our red lines?

00:14:19:25 – 00:14:39:24
Anne
Are they clear. You know, do we sort of forget them when there’s a bit more money on offer, you know, or do we carry that through and say, well, this this is how we, this is how we’re going to operate. This is what we stand for. This is our personal code of ethics. This is the respect that we’re going to show to others.

00:14:39:24 – 00:15:11:10
Anne
This is how we’re going to work with them. And that’s, you know, about policies, but it’s also about leadership example as well. I think, Tony, and I’m not being personal here, but, you know, people in organizations model what they see. Yeah. And so and I think this is part of our role as senior people within organizations as well, that the the modeling of the right behavior, the taking the right decision, even though it’s going to cost you, you know, is how we need to do things.

00:15:11:10 – 00:15:34:10
Anne
So turning down business some sorry, I don’t want to be associated with that brand because it has, you know, it’s always working and not acceptable to us. But it also means, you know, things like, showing a level of reciprocity or what do we do pro bono that tells a story about you. You know, what do we do that’s over?

00:15:34:10 – 00:16:03:25
Anne
And above that tells a story about you. How do we treat our employees? That tells a story about. That’s the corporate narrative, much more powerful than the story that a journalist might cobble together on our behalf. Or we might want to say, you know, this is our narrative because that disjoint between what we say, the story we tell, and the reality of everyday experience of us is the legitimacy gap.

00:16:03:28 – 00:16:11:05
Anne
And so we need to bring those two things closer and closer together. So we are what we say.

00:16:11:07 – 00:16:32:28
Tony
Yeah. And and and that that’s a really interesting one that, you know, a fair bit of soul searching has to go on. But I think if you can live to your kind of personal values, from my perspective anyway, you know, we try to create something here at Viva that is strong and solid and, you know, we we do what it says on on the tin kind of approach and.

00:16:33:05 – 00:16:34:21
Tony
Yeah, yeah.

00:16:34:22 – 00:16:38:22
Anne
And, you know, your job choice says something about your values doesn’t it.

00:16:38:24 – 00:17:05:28
Tony
Yeah. Yeah. Interesting. So let’s let’s move on. Let’s look at leadership rather than management. And this seats at the top table kind of discussion. That seems to be as long running as I’ve been in the industry. And and you know, you’ve come at it from a really particularly interesting angle, I think, because you don’t accept that PR is a management function at all.

00:17:05:29 – 00:17:15:19
Tony
And I think that will raise a few eyebrows. So forgive me if I’ve got that wrong, but, you know, I think that’s an interesting place to start this.

00:17:15:22 – 00:17:42:12
Anne
Yeah, well, we are a management discipline in one way, and there is a Department of Public Relations or corporate Communications normally. But I think that actually undervalues us, because if you think about an organizational chart, what you normally have is the bosses at the top, and then you’ll have HR and operations and legal and public relations, and they all have their boss of those functions.

00:17:42:12 – 00:18:07:07
Anne
And some of those bosses will be in the boardroom and and some won’t. So if we’re just a management function, we run the risk of not being involved in all the senior decisions. But I think there’s much more profound about public relations. So if we think about an organization, you can take the money away and you can have an organization.

00:18:07:10 – 00:18:29:28
Anne
You take the buildings away, as we did in Covid. You can have an organization, you know, if you take communication away, you cannot have an organization unless people talk to each other. The boss shares a vision, unless we share our tasks and agree what we’re going to do. And we make decisions and we talk to others who might buy our products or whatever.

00:18:30:00 – 00:19:12:04
Anne
You don’t have an organization. And I think, you know that transfer nature of communication is really important because you can take that at every level, the senior management level, you know, in the leadership cadre, if you like, unless they’re understanding the public relations elements of their decision making. So unless they understand what stakeholders are going to tolerate or support or object to, and unless they understand what’s going on out there in terms of the trends that are affecting people’s lives and the context in which those decisions are going to be received and the context in which they need to be made, they’re not going to make good decisions.

00:19:12:06 – 00:19:42:29
Anne
And furthermore, you know, as the delivery part of our job, when we talk to people about those decisions, if those have not been properly calibrated and if they are not, you know, cognizant of of the expectations of people, they’re not going to be supported or accepted. And if you think about that at every level. So that’s internally with employees, externally with whoever community you want to choose.

00:19:43:01 – 00:20:14:04
Anne
Unless you get that right, then you’re not going to have a successful organization. You may not have an organization at all. So for me, there is something about unless you believe that communication is embedded in leadership and enacted through leadership, you know, through the decisions that they make, you’re missing something essential because those organizational charts show everything being subservient to leadership.

00:20:14:04 – 00:20:43:12
Anne
They all live nicely underneath in little silo columns. We’re not like that. We have to be, you know, everywhere, in everything, looking at every decision that’s being made, looking at the impact of on, on a range of stakeholders and holding the truth up to the reality of that decision making to leadership, because they ultimately are responsible for those decisions.

00:20:43:15 – 00:21:07:17
Anne
And therefore, that’s why I think that unless public relations is regarded as a leadership decision and that our place is in leadership decision making, not in management, which is about effectiveness and efficiency of implementing decisions, but part of the decision making. I think we are doing a big disservice to our profession.

00:21:07:19 – 00:21:36:06
Tony
That’s a really interesting take, and I really like that idea where you boil it down in terms of like, you know, if you take away the different structures that the physical ones of an organization, and, you know, without communication, it’s nothing. It doesn’t exist. That’s, that’s one of those. Yes, I like that like that a lot. And you said everything a leader does should be seen through a communication lens.

00:21:36:09 – 00:21:51:21
Tony
Plenty of chief executives, in my experience, think they’ve got that covered because they can post something and, you know, make videos these days and so on. How do we get through to them?

00:21:51:23 – 00:22:17:27
Anne
Yeah, it’s it’s a lifelong problem, isn’t it? But for me, you know, doing the social media, it’s important, but it’s tactical. Yeah. And I go back to this. It’s about behavior, stupid, you know? So if their actions and their decisions give the lie to the nice move words on the video, you know, they are going to have a huge problem.

00:22:17:29 – 00:22:45:06
Anne
They’re going to lose their legitimacy, their support as a leader. And they’re going to destroy trust because this gap is very, very observable these days. So I think that holding the mirror up to say, this is what you’re saying, this is what you’re doing, and get them to ask the question. Now, if I was observing this, what would what would I think?

00:22:45:07 – 00:23:33:04
Anne
What would you think? Yeah. And, I think a lot of chief executives actually get this now, Tony. Yeah, I think they do understand that, you know, their reputation is really, really important. And actually, if they are out there on the TikTok videos, etcetera, etcetera, what they what they say is becoming increasingly obvious. But people look at the nature of the organization, the character of the organization, and they say, you know, the leadership embodies the values of that organization, not what they put in the nice words above the front door, but the values that they actually live day by day.

00:23:33:06 – 00:23:54:17
Anne
And again, if they see this gap, then that chief executive is going to be more accountable than when they just kept their mouth shut, or if they got somebody else to speak on on their behalf because they are saying it and their behaviors are laid bare, you know, because these are the decisions that they make.

00:23:54:19 – 00:24:13:22
Tony
That’s. Yeah, that’s that’s a really good one. I mean, we looked at it through the lens of the chief executive, but also as practitioners, what do we do to become better at becoming that trusted leadership advocate or advisor?

00:24:13:24 – 00:24:42:12
Anne
Yeah. So I think this is an interesting one because our comfort blanket is doing stuff. Yeah, we are fixers and doers. You know, it’s characteristic of people in our profession. You know, we’re energetic, we change things. We get on with things. You know, we crack on and and make a difference. And I think if we retain S.O.S., you know, sending out stuff as a priority.

00:24:42:15 – 00:25:12:00
Anne
Yeah. Then we we’ve got a challenge and, and we need to focus on what matters to the organization in the long run. So this thing about, you know, making sense of what’s going on. In a time of real and shape, uncertainty is really important. Understanding the risks that organizations are facing and talking about those things. You know, as I say, you know, you are what you say, what you talk about, really.

00:25:12:04 – 00:25:36:11
Anne
So if you’re constantly talking about I’ll do a bit of content for TikTok or this, that and the other, that’s how you’ll be labeled. No wonder people say, come and deliver this for me. You’re really good at TikTok. You know, instead of saying, oh, this person is talking about the risks we face as an organization, I never realized that that stakeholder group up there were really upset with us, and that we need to do something about that.

00:25:36:12 – 00:26:04:03
Anne
I never realized, actually, that there’s a community around us that’s really hacked off because our lorries are going through at 6:00 in the morning, you know, and they’ve told us this because they’re talking to them every day. And this is what it means in terms of our reputation. And increasingly, you know, some of those governance issues. I talked about character now, but particularly with AI come in on, on the scene, you know, and how people perceive AI.

00:26:04:05 – 00:26:31:19
Anne
These are huge issues of risk for organizations. These are the sorts of things that we ought to be talking about keeping the organization save money. Maintaining its license to operate, you know, understanding what’s going out there, interpreting, forecasting what’s going to happen in the near future, sort of forecasting, but also realizing what’s coming up at the rear to that might come back and bite it.

00:26:31:21 – 00:26:51:13
Anne
These are the real value adding perspectives that we can give. And getting the organization culture right, you know, as it goes through enormous change as it is at the moment. These are the tasks that we we should be involved in because these things make a difference.

00:26:51:16 – 00:26:51:29
Tony
Yeah.

00:26:52:00 – 00:26:55:15
Anne
No. Another TikTok won’t.

00:26:55:17 – 00:27:16:04
Tony
That’s really interesting. I was, recording one of these sessions with a lady called Haley James the other day, and I asked her the classic seat at the top table question, and her reply was, we should have a seat at every table. We should be on that listening road and be plugged into all the conversations that are going.

00:27:16:04 – 00:27:18:06
Tony
Just to your point, really?

00:27:18:09 – 00:27:41:21
Anne
Yeah. Absolutely. Right. You know, I’ve got a big nose and I, I, I regard it is really important that it’s in everybody’s business not to be nosy, but because you know, two things. You know what’s going on. You get a sense of smell and feel of the place. And that’s really important because that’s about I hate this word, but, you know, this authenticity.

00:27:41:23 – 00:28:02:11
Anne
You know what? What we really like. It’s really important, those watercooler moments, just finding out what’s going on. You know what the really great things are, what the potential issues are. They’re all talked about. I know we don’t have watercooler moments very often these days. You know what I mean? There. It’s just getting a sense for the organization.

00:28:02:13 – 00:28:30:10
Anne
But also it’s really important we do that externally and internally. And sometimes we get ourselves into little silos where we talk to the same people internally and externally, and we need to be like a rash, like everywhere on every table. She’s dead. Right. You know, finding out what’s going on sent this thing about sensing I like it a little bit to a, like, a spider in the spider’s web, you know, spider gravitates towards the middle.

00:28:30:11 – 00:28:47:09
Anne
But every now and then as to pop out and talk to this group, or there’s a bit of tension here, I better go and find out what’s landing, you know, and then it’s off to another place. There’s something happening in the web here that I need to understand and what’s going on. And something nice has happened over here.

00:28:47:09 – 00:28:51:03
Anne
So everywhere. Yeah. Absolutely. Right. I’d agree with that.

00:28:51:05 – 00:29:19:12
Tony
Excellent. You mentioned AI in your last book. One answer. And for for listeners and viewers, this is where the this whole episode got kicked off at the AI and PR conference earlier this year, where I bumped into it, I got introduced around, should I say, and, you created a bit of a mic drop moment that morning at one of the early sessions where where you said one of the phrases that really trouble you was human in the loop.

00:29:19:15 – 00:29:33:15
Tony
And you, you said that it should be replaced by human at the helm. And I’ve been using that ever since. But I have been crediting you, obviously. But what did you mean by that? Like, I’ll let you take back ownership of that phrase.

00:29:33:17 – 00:30:02:01
Anne
Yeah, well, if we talk about humans in the loop. Well, it just it sounds a little bit that we’re in incidental. You know, we’re in the loop, but we’re not actually in control. And it’s interesting, isn’t it? The discussions that we’ve been having over this last week or two, more broadly on the news about some of the AI leaders really worried about where AI is taking us and wanting humans to be in control and wanting regulation.

00:30:02:04 – 00:30:22:04
Anne
And I think I absolutely agree with them there. And, and we’re struggling to get to a place where we can agree that. But it’s really, really important. This is the most potent technology that has ever existed, and we have the least guidelines on it. As Ian Hargreaves said, you know, there’s more regulation over a sandwich and there is over AI.

00:30:22:07 – 00:30:45:15
Anne
And it’s true, you know, you have health warnings, you know where the nuts are, you know, and all the rest of it on sandwiches. There have none of that for AI. And if it’s human in the loop, it sounds as if what’s really important is the AI. Yeah. The rest of the loop that we should be at the helm because it’s human beings that are being affected by this.

00:30:45:17 – 00:31:08:23
Anne
It’s human beings who are losing their jobs. He’s young people who can’t find a career forward. He’s human beings that will be affected by AI if it goes rogue, you know? And, AI doesn’t matter if it lives or dies, it matters if if humanity lives or dies. Well, it does to me anyway, you know, and and therefore we should be in control.

00:31:08:25 – 00:31:35:04
Anne
And it’s, you know, a is is purely shapes our realities. It’s a really powerful stakeholder in what we do. And I think unless we have human beings front and central, we think we’re going to be really effective and really efficient in our jobs so we can produce all sorts of clever things, you know, with minimum effort. Unless we think through the implications of this, we’re going to be in danger.

00:31:35:04 – 00:31:52:00
Anne
And I don’t just mean, you know, rogue AI, I think we’re going to lose the ability to think because we are our, you know, our thinking muscles or wither because I’ll do it all for us. And human beings will become less and less important in that loop.

00:31:52:03 – 00:32:14:13
Tony
Do you think that, you know, we risk losing our legitimacy as a, as a communications function as well as as those professionals and as AI can take on some of the deliverable tasks to A, to a, to a standard, and is there a risk there as well?

00:32:14:16 – 00:32:40:06
Anne
Yes. I mean and and we’ve got to I think we’ve got to keep this in perspective. But yes, it as I say, the pressure particularly on organizations, because we’re not in good economic circumstances around the world, really, is to just capitalize on what we think are the efficiencies of AI. And as we see, you know, there’s been a pause on youth employment and entry level jobs.

00:32:40:10 – 00:33:18:03
Anne
But actually it’s a very short term perspective. And if we think about our our profession, unless you know how to write, how are you going to correct AI written text unless you know how to research? How do you know that the data on which it’s basing its content is okay, unless we know how to, interrogate things and unless we know how to critically analyze things, how are we going to make those judgments about, well, this is the right thing to do in this circumstance.

00:33:18:05 – 00:33:22:16
Anne
And so I think with AI.

00:33:22:18 – 00:33:54:15
Anne
They’re fantastic assistance, you know, and they take the judge out of so much work. But as we go further up the food chain and our job becomes more about oversight, we still have to know the basic skills in order to make sure that what the tools are doing are right. And what’s more, mentioned earlier, the idea of, of of governance within organizations, people are worried about the nature of their data, how it’s been collectors, how it’s been aggregated, how it’s being used.

00:33:54:16 – 00:34:24:04
Anne
People are worried about these algorithms, you know, that. I don’t know what’s going on in 98% of the world, because algorithm will only gives me 2% and reinforces that all, all the time. People are worried about that. People are worried about privacy. They’re worried about, you know, a digitally disenfranchized group groups, often older, but also those people don’t have the resources necessary to get all the training that they need.

00:34:24:07 – 00:34:47:09
Anne
So governance is going to become really important. And if we think about organizations, they’re going to be questioned as well. What are you doing with AI? Why are you making all these people redundant? Why should I pay more tax to pay them on employment benefit when you’re making them redundant? Look how you’re changing society. Can’t get on the phone and talk to anybody anymore.

00:34:47:13 – 00:35:07:07
Anne
I don’t want to talk to an AI agent. I want to talk to a human being. All these questions that people are asking are legitimate. And, you know, whoever we work for, we’re going to be held to account for those things. And I think we need to be there in that space saying, these are the questions that people are asking.

00:35:07:09 – 00:35:15:29
Anne
Mr. Chief Executive, Mrs. Chief Executive what’s our position on this? How can we justify what we’re doing.

00:35:16:01 – 00:35:32:23
Tony
When we have this, set up call to, to discuss this podcast? You talked and you mentioned it in earlier as well, that, we should be viewing AI as a stakeholder. What do you mean by that? And what do we do about it?

00:35:32:25 – 00:36:05:19
Anne
So yeah, I think it’s quite controversial. And not everybody regards AI as a stakeholder because it can’t make ethical decisions. It’s it’s programed. But even if you don’t call it a stakeholder, and I’d say it is in that it is something that affects what we do and it affects what, how we think about the world. Call it a powerful actor if you like, but it’s, it’s it’s a major intervener in our information ecosystem.

00:36:05:24 – 00:36:29:23
Anne
It shapes our reality. I say, you know, I just get a fraction of reality coming to me because the algorithms determine what’s going to come to me when I go online. So it controls what we see. It shapes how I perceive you, Tony. Perceive organization. It shapes how people perceive a whole organizations and what is true about them.

00:36:30:00 – 00:36:58:21
Anne
It mediates our engagement with others and it determines through AI summaries. For example, what what is accepting increasingly accepted to be the truth? You know, all the research says that people believe AI summaries. We don’t know where it’s got all this stuff from to come up with those summaries. We don’t know if they’re biased. We don’t know if they’re stolen somebody’s data to present that information to us.

00:36:58:25 – 00:37:35:21
Anne
So they might not have intentionality, so they might not be ethically liable, AI bots or whatever, but they certainly handle order, shape, present information in a way that is incredibly persuasive and compelling. And I don’t think we can afford to underestimate the power of that, and we ignore it at our peril. And so I say it’s a stakeholder because, just as you might persuade me as a particular point of view, Tony, it persuades me of a particular point of view.

00:37:35:23 – 00:38:08:10
Anne
And by, by the way, that it, organization organizes information that’s coming to me and the way it presents it. So I think we, we need to think really carefully about this and not lose that critical questioning ability. Why does it say this? Whose interest does this serve? You know, some pretty big actors there with a lot of money who are dependent on maintaining our dependance on the attention economy?

00:38:08:12 – 00:38:19:19
Anne
Why are they doing it? You know, they’re good actors or are they bad actors? Are they wanted money? Are they wanting power? Are they just cruel? You know, these are questions we should ask.

00:38:19:22 – 00:38:34:24
Tony
It goes back to that that that human at the helm. Idea that it’s much broader than controlling the AI. It’s it’s it’s it’s taking that step back or the helicopter view as well, isn’t it?

00:38:34:27 – 00:38:47:07
Anne
That’s right, that’s right. And at the end of the day, we decide what sort of society we want. And, you know, the time to make those decisions is now.

00:38:47:10 – 00:39:09:23
Tony
For for comes leaders looking at the organization, adopting AI at speed. How do they keep that human, thought process? How do they keep the themselves, you know, involved or the organization safe through all this?

00:39:09:25 – 00:39:41:21
Anne
I think they need some awkward people. Yeah. People like PR people asking those awkward questions. Not because they’re awkward, because other people are asking those questions and holding that mirror up. You know, that reality check up, I think is really important. I think we can turn to guidelines, and we know there are guidelines by CI and by ICO, and make sure etc. about how we might think about approaching AI.

00:39:41:22 – 00:40:05:18
Anne
But the key thing for me, Tony, is about implementation. How do we actually do this on a day to day basis? And a number of organizations, Rolls-Royce is a good example actually. They’ve got something called the Althea Framework, where they say these are the principles of the framework and their values based, you know, so are we doing harm to society?

00:40:05:24 – 00:40:36:15
Anne
Are we enhancing the good of people who are dependent on us, etc., etc.? So their values base, but also, they do like a little audit tool. So okay, so we’ve got this and we’re going to do that. So how how is it created. Do we know the source is reliable. Do we know that the developer is is well respected, acts with integrity, integrity, etc., etc.?

00:40:36:17 – 00:41:02:23
Anne
And then when we actually implement it, who’s going to be affected by this? How are they going to be affected? Who’s going to benefit from this? Who’s going to be harmed potentially by this? And then, you know, who have we got questioning our processes? Do we have a proper governance procedure. And it’s like an audit tool. So if somebody does come along to you and say, I don’t like what you’re doing with your AI, you can say, well, here is the evidence.

00:41:02:23 – 00:41:38:19
Anne
Of what? Of the, you know, the, the the audit track of what we’ve done, how we’ve taken our decisions. You might not agree with it, but I’ve got a transparent process here that I can show you where we have considered those things. And as we know, not everybody could do what we want all the time. But at least there’s a process that we’ve gone through and I think could quite rightly be looked over by PR because we are independent, you know, of a particular functional view, and we do act on behalf of stakeholders.

00:41:38:19 – 00:41:59:12
Anne
So I think it’s quite important that we do that and where we can involve outside outsiders in that, in that process, maybe there are particular issues that might get a little expert panel together for we should do that so that we can demonstrate, you know, that there’s integrity in what we do.

00:41:59:15 – 00:42:30:22
Tony
Excellent. We’re coming to, to to a clause now for a wrap up. And, I mean, you’ve been a thought leader within this PR and comms for for more than a while now. Shall was there. And and I’m I’m intrigued. Whenever I meet someone like yourself who creates a opinions and, you know, in opinion, a leader that people will follow, where do you turn to for inspiration?

00:42:30:22 – 00:42:36:19
Tony
Who do you, follow and read and think about?

00:42:36:22 – 00:43:03:16
Anne
Well, thank you for those kind words. I’ve got the scars on me back, Tony. It comes often through experience in age, doesn’t it? They sort of thinking, oh well, yeah, I’ve been here before and I’ve learned some lessons, hopefully. But yeah, well, I’m a real jackdaw, actually, Tony, I go everywhere and anywhere really, because I think it’s really important to have multiple perspectives on things.

00:43:03:18 – 00:43:30:10
Anne
So, you know, I love the BBC. I’m sorry, I’m really old fashioned, but at least it’s a very fide source, you know? And it’s, it’s it’s open to scrutiny. I think that’s really important. But I’ll also go to a range of other perspectives. Left wing, right wing, center, overseas perspectives of what’s going on. So, you know, Washington Post, Al Jazeera, a whole range to try and get a proper and holistic view of what’s going on.

00:43:30:12 – 00:43:55:05
Anne
But in terms of of PR, if you like, and our discipline. Well, there are certain, you know, leaders who are much Sadia and wiser than me, some of them specialists like Tony Jakes in In Crisis Communication. But Kathy Arrow from New Zealand, I think is a wonderful thinker about PR Simon Bore, you know, who’s chief executive of the Government Communications Service.

00:43:55:09 – 00:44:33:03
Anne
Profound thinking about what’s happening in government and public sector comms, government communications itself as a website, which is hugely impactful. And people should look at it. You know, the wall of belief stuff is is amazing stuff. Organizations like PRCA, some of the overseas associations, like the Canadian Institute is fantastic and PR, but also I like looking at what our outsiders say about us because we do an awful lot of navel gazing in our industry.

00:44:33:03 – 00:44:55:29
Anne
So I, I do read the reports by McKinsey’s and Deloitte and Ipsos and University of Southern California. I think they’re really insightful. But I guess what I’m saying is everything everywhere, all at once. Tony, you know, I like I like just trying to keep a broad perspective. And then you can, you know, try and integrate that and think things through.

00:44:55:29 – 00:45:17:13
Anne
So I wouldn’t I wouldn’t be comfortable just going to a single source all the time because of what we’ve been talking about. You know, all that just narrows your perspective really. And you can generate your own algorithms by just going to certain people. But if you keep your perspective broad, I think it’s really helpful.

00:45:17:16 – 00:45:32:11
Tony
Excellent. Well, and I’m sure you’ll have opened some eyes and ears today. It’s been a really insightful chat and really appreciate the time that you’ve given us. It’s been excellent. Thanks again.

00:45:32:13 – 00:45:43:27
Anne
Thank you. Tony, you’ve asked me some hard questions, as all good interviewers do, so thank you very much indeed. It’s been a pleasure to be to have this discussion with you.

00:45:43:29 – 00:45:58:22
Tony
Thanks for listening to PR in the Real World with me, Tony Garner. If you like what you’ve heard, it’d be great if you could subscribe and like and share. Spread the word. Basically help others find this great content. Thanks again for listening. Tune in next time.

Apple podcast
Spotify podcast

ARCHIVES

RECENT PROJECTS

looking for a PR agency that delivers